1st attempt at Lahey's No-Knead as a Loaf

5 posts / 0 new
Last post
strikingtwice's picture
strikingtwice
Offline
Joined: 2011-05-19 07:33
1st attempt at Lahey's No-Knead as a Loaf

So one of the issues that i've been running into with the no knead bread recipe from My Bread by Jim Lahey (run and get it immediately if you don't have it), is that it's not great for sandwiches. The boule that it makes is beautiful beyond belief and delicious, but the inconsistent natural shape doesn't give you a lot of sandwich worthy height. 

One of the main points of the cooking method (read about the whole method in the book), is that it's done in a cast iron dutch oven. An oven within an oven. It's meant to replicate a closed door wood burning stove (more accurately, an ancient roman clay oven). Instead, today I used a super cheap loaf pan that I got from The Restaurant Store or http://www.webstaurantstore.com. I covered it pretty tightly with tented foil for the first 30 minutes, then uncovered for the next 15-20.

Also, before the second quick fermentation, I gave it a couple of folds. The no-knead bread produces a very light open crumb, one that is not ideal for sandwiches. With a few folds and some VERY light palm presses, I squeezed together some of the dough. Then cooked. The result is a beautiful looking loaf of bread, but I still can't get the height I want. I'm thinking more dough for the batch? Is my solution that simple? Thanks everyone, enjoy the pics.

If you can't view the pictures, here's a link.

http://smg.photobucket.com/albums/v637/strikingtwice/

esavitzky's picture
esavitzky
Offline
Joined: 2011-05-16 07:13

Hi Dave,

I had a similar problem with my sourdough and Chef Jacob suggested I reduce my % of water to 60% from 70%.  This made a difference in height but at the same time increased the density of the bread thus yielding less of an airy crumb.  I have been experimenting with different percentages between 60% and 70% and will eventually find a balance that works.  I also use the cast iron dutch oven.  

Hopefully Jacob will release the second part of the bread series podcasts to provide some insight  on going from dough to a nicely prepared boule that gets a good spring and has a great crust and crumb.  Most of what I am doing now is based on the help he has provided that you will find in the sourdough thread.

By the way, your link is password protected.

Elliot

strikingtwice's picture
strikingtwice
Offline
Joined: 2011-05-19 07:33

Elliot, try the link again.

I actually have no problems with the boule, I want to do loaves now, and this is the problem. I've been trying to replicate the cooking method in a loaf form. I will try the hydration change. Thanks.

esavitzky's picture
esavitzky
Offline
Joined: 2011-05-16 07:13

Dave, and watched a youtube video of him preparing the no knead recipe just a little while ago.

The recipe I use for sourdough is very different and of course doesnt even include anything other than natural yeast from the starter.

So the hydration rates I use are very different than what Leahy uses.  He actually uses a 50% hydration rate with the 1 1/2 cups water to 3 cups of flour.  So I really cant help you out here.

I was intrigued by the video though that  I just mixed up a batch and am letting is proof over night and into tomorrow.

I did change the recipe somewhat and converted to grams as cup measures are not really replicable.

I decided to use a mixture of 85% bread flour and 15 % whole wheat flour.  I'll let you know how it turns out.

Sorry for any confusion as the confusion was all mine.

Elliot

strikingtwice's picture
strikingtwice
Offline
Joined: 2011-05-19 07:33

The best mix that I've found for the lahey method is 50 50 bread/AP.

The recipe from the book is as follows
flour 400g
yeast 1g
salt 9g
water 300g

His hydration is actually 75%.

Hope it turns out well, as long as you don't handle it a whole lot, it usually does. It also doesn't need the sourdough starter as much because the long ferment really creates a lot of the alcohol and sour.

Enjoy.

Newest Forum Topics

I have been amazed at how nice Mucho does his beef brisket and the bark on the meat.

I used to do that but changed processes but what changed, what am I doing different today? I bought an electric smoker for convenience. So what is the difference between wood in an electric and wood in a wood or charcoal smoker?

Comments: 1

I decided to try an overnight rise in a refridgerator, about 5C

Dough made up with the recipe I posted previously:

600gm strong flour,
390gm water,
10gm oil
10 gm salt
3 gm yeast

I covered the bowl with cling film and left it for about 10 hours.

The dough rose just less than double. It formed a skin, which may explain the limited rise. Perhaps I might try painting it with oil next time.

The texture was very sticky. I covered my hands with oil and divided it up into two separate lots.

Comments: 0

Hey everyone!

I've been reading through these forums, they are chock full of awesome information. Thank you all for taking the time to post interesting things, a day spent without learning something is a day wasted :)

Would anyone be interested in reading the Vacuum Sealer buyer's gude that I wrote a little bit ago? I'm pretty surprised by how few of my friends Sous Vide, especially since so many of them like to cook. 

I wrote the guide after struggling with choosing a vacuum sealer myself...so I was hoping to help anyone in a similar situation.

Comments: 1

Cook's Science has figured out the relationship of water and rice for Sous Vide.

The ratio is 1:1 at 200 F.

What changes is the grain.
White long grain rice is 25 minutes
Brown, Red, Black rice is 65 minutes

So I cooked my normal beans, Sous Vide and then cooked cooked two rices, long grain white and brown rice for the allotted time and mixed together with the beans.

I flavored with a Chinese spice, alcohol and oil blend that I use for Kung Pao Chicken.

The beans were meaty and the rice was al dente.

Chris

Comments: 0

This is an interesting on line calculator that was developed by some students at MIT for meat cooking times in the Science of Cooking class.

https://groups.csail.mit.edu/uid/science-of-cooking/home-screen.html 

I did a Make Your Own chart
You can toggle between C or F in the top right corner. Time is in minutes 1 hour equals 60:00 minutes

Meat Type Turkey

Thickness 5 cm
Starting at 40 F

Comments: 0